Scientists
who study and measure human behavior find that buying a home is one of the most
stressful experiences of our lives. Contributing significantly to this anxiety
is waiting for the mortgage to be approved. Much of the homebuyers' unease
results from not knowing what is going on. You know credit checks and
verifications of employment are taking place-but what makes the difference
between getting or not getting that loan, and how long does it take? This page
can dispel at least some of that anxiety by detailing the steps the lender takes
in making the loan decision-process called "underwriting." Listed below are the
topics addressed on this page.
Are You a Good Risk?
Just as
wise stock market investors carefully research the companies in which they plan
to buy stock, careful mortgage lenders investigate the financial background of
each loan applicant. In lending the prospective homebuyer the money to buy the
home, the lender assumes a long-term risk. The assumption is that the borrower
is going to eventually repay the loan and in the meantime make the loan payments
on time.
Once all the information is
collected and eligibility is established, the lender decides whether to extend
the homebuyer credit. In other words, lenders analyze the risk of lending
(making the investment), and match it to an appropriate interest rate and loan
term.
There are no established,
industry-wide standards for underwriting, though most lenders follow standards
set by government-related agencies, private mortgage insurers, private mortgage
investors or institutional investors. The vast majority of mortgage lenders
attempt to approve a loan application if at all prudently possible, but to
approve a loan that will become delinquent serves no one's best interest. The
burden falls on the lender to establish that an applicant is qualified.
The Initial Interview
The process usually begins with an interview where the
prospective borrowers and a representative of the lender sit down to discuss the
potential loan. Increasingly, however, lenders are not requiring a face-to-face
meeting and accept a completed application by mail. Many lenders today will even
qualify you for a loan before you begin to shop for a home. Many lenders
advertise this service in the local newspaper, but any lender can provide it.
Knowing approximately how much money you are qualified to borrow can save you
time and prevent disappointment when you are looking at houses.
When going to
see a lender for an initial interview, you should take:
- Purchase contract for the
house if you have one.
- Certificate of Eligibility
from the Veterans Administration (VA) if you want a VA loan. (Note: If you
do not have one, the lender will obtain the information for you from your
service records.
- Bank account numbers and the
address of your bank branch. This will save the lender time in checking your
credit.
- Credit card bills for the
past several billing periods.
- Pay stubs, W2 forms or other
proof of employment and salary.
- If you are self-employed, you
should be able to present balance sheets, tax returns and other information
about your business.
The important
document that gets the whole process rolling is the loan application. It asks
in-depth questions concerning you, your income, assets and liabilities, your
credit, and your legal history, as well as a description of the property you
wish to buy. The lender will verify the information you provide on the
application before making the decision whether to extend the loan.
Applicants
usually will know after the initial interview if they are qualified for the type
and size of loan they want. Lenders try to let the borrower know as quickly as
possible if they really are not qualified for the size of loan that they
request.
Consumer Safeguards
The initial interview sets in
motion some important consumer safeguards. The Truth-in-Lending disclosure
requirements provide the applicant with an estimated yearly cost for the loan -
the
Annual Percentage Rate (APR). The other important disclosure that
follows from the
Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), a federal
law. This requires lenders to provide homebuyers with information on known and
estimated closing costs.
The initial interview also starts
a clock that will allow applicants to know whether or not they have been
approved in about 30 to 60 days from the submission of a completed application.
If the loan is denied, the lender must disclose the specific reason (s) for the
rejection.
Is Your Income Sufficient?
Following the
initial interview, or loan application, the first step the lender takes is to
verify your employment or income. This is done by mailing employment and income
forms to current and past employers, and it will help the lender determine how
much debt you can successfully take on.
Income Requirements
A general
rule is that you can qualify for a loan of up to twice the family's income (i.e.
a family with income of $30,000 a year usually can qualify for a mortgage of up
to $60,000). Often, the amount you earn may not be as important as how you earn
it. Bonuses and commissions can vary greatly from year to year, and lenders are
reluctant to depend on them if they make up a large percentage of your income.
There are similar problems when a large portion of your salary is based on
overtime pay, and you rely on it to qualify for the loan. In the case of bonuses
and commissions, the lender will want to verify your bonus and commission status
back two or three years to get a better idea of what you earn from those sources
on average. In the case of overtime, the lender will establish whether the work
is expected to continue and whether or not the amount of overtime income is
reasonable for the extra work. After establishing these points, the mortgage
lender will make a decision as to how much to allow for these additional sources
of income.
If you are
self-employed, you should plan on producing a balance sheet, profit and loss
statements and copies of your federal income tax returns for the past two or
three years. Tax returns may also be required to verify other income claims,
such as when income from securities is a major source for mortgage payments.
Income/Expense Standards
Your
lender will work out these figures for you when you sit down to discuss the
mortgage you want.
Lenders
generally say that housing expenses (including mortgage payments, insurance,
taxes and special assessments) should not exceed 25 percent to 28 percent of the
homeowner's gross monthly income. For Federal Housing Administration (FHA)
loans, this figure is not to exceed 29 percent of the homebuyer's gross monthly
income. With loans guaranteed by the Department of Veteran's Affairs (VA),
lenders measure prospective homebuyers with
Residual Income, or the
monthly income minus expenses. The remainder is then measured against
geographical and family size data to qualify the borrower.
- FHA Loans
- Housing Expenses = 29% gross monthly income
- Housing Expenses plus Long-Term Debt = 41% gross monthly income
Debt
Lenders usually
define long-term debt as monthly expenses extending more than 10 months into the
future. These expenses should not exceed 33 percent to 36 percent of the
homeowner's gross monthly income. FHA-insured mortgage lenders define long-term
debt as monthly expenses extending 12 months or more into the future, and look
for these expenses plus housing expenses not to exceed 41 percent of the
homeowner's gross monthly income.
Is Your Credit Good?
Before extending credit, lenders will want to examine the risk of not getting the money
back. To do this lenders will look at four crucial aspects of your credit
history when you apply for a mortgage:
- History of past credit - what were the
size and terms of past loans?
- Type of Credit - have you obtained real
estate, auto, personal or other installment loans in the past?
- Lapses in employment or debt repayment -
are active accounts current , and is there any recent bankruptcy or
judgment?
- - how many unexplained lapses are there, and for
how long?
From the information uncovered by these four questions, lenders can develop a fair idea
of just how you will handle your responsibilities once you have signed the
contract for repaying the loan. However, lenders cannot examine everything when
putting together a credit history. They have two extremely important limitations
on credit information gathering.
Credit Information
Safeguards
The first
limitation is the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which was designed to ensure fair
and accurate consumer credit reporting. The Fair Credit Reporting Act stipulates
that lenders must certify the purpose for which the information is sought and
use it for no other purpose. The Act also prohibits reports based on subjective
information from neighbors and others concerning character, general reputation
and other personal aspects. Certain other credit information, such as bankruptcy
more than seven years before, is also prohibited unless the principal involved
in the action was $50,000 or more.
The second
consumer safeguard limiting the credit information lenders can use to make a
mortgage decision is the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (
ECOA). ECOA
prohibits discrimination in lending based on race, color, national origin, sex,
marital status, age (provided the applicant may legally contract), and the fact
that all or part of the applicant's income comes from a public assistance
program.
Lender's
are also prohibited by law from asking:
- questions concerning the applicant's spouse, unless
- the spouse will be
contractually liable,
- the spouse's income will be used to qualify,
- the applicants live in
a community property state, or
- the applicant will use
child support, alimony or separate maintenance payments from a spouse or
former spouse to qualify.
- questions concerning future parenting plans.
(although the lender may ask the ages and current number of children the
applicant has)
Can You Make The Down Payment?
Lenders
expect homebuyers to have enough money available to make the down payment of
between 10 and 20 percent of the asking price for the house-though FHA and VA
loans require smaller down payment (0 to 5 percent) and to pay their share of
the closing costs (3 percent to 6 percent of the loan amount). If, however, you
cannot come up with a 20 percent down payment, a lender can make you a loan for
as little as 5 percent down. He will, however, require you to carry private
mortgage insurance for conventional (not FHA or VA loans), for which you will
pay a premium for the first year and an additional monthly fee in subsequent
years.
Sources on
which prospective homebuyers may draw for the down payment and the closing costs
include savings, stocks/bonds, Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), pension
funds, real state holdings, life insurance policies, mutual funds or employee
savings plans.
Homebuyers
may also rely on another source of funding for the down payment-a gift, or money
given by a parent or other relative that need not be repaid. a person may give
another person up to $10,000 per year without either party being taxed. A
married couple, therefore, could give a child or spouse as much as $40,000 for a
down payment tax-free. Remember, however, that if you use gift money for a down
payment, you will need to present a letter so stating and signed by both the
giver(s) and the receiver(s) to your lender.
Mortgage
lenders send a form to the homebuyer's savings institution(s) to verify the
amount available for purchasing the house, as well as the amount of outstanding
loans with that institution.
Is The House Worth
The Price?
Mortgage
lenders also examine the real estate being purchased to make sure that, in case
of foreclosure, the lender has a salable property. The property's acceptability
is established by an independent appraisal.
The
appraiser looks not only at what the home is worth today, but how the
neighborhood's dynamics will affect the property value in the future. The three
main points the appraiser checks are:
- Physical security of the property.
- age, structural soundness, landscaping, etc.
- Location.
- The kind of neighborhood, surrounding houses, access to transportation, commercial development nearby, etc.
- Local government's plans for the area.
- how zoning and taxes will affect the property in the years to come.
Do I Get The Loan?
Your
lender has made all the checks. Your income, credit, assets, property and all
necessary documentation have been scrutinized. Now comes the big decision.
If the
lender's decision is to extend the credit, you will be notified, usually through
a commitment letter. The mortgage lender can approve the homebuyer for the
entire amount asked for, or a lesser amount based on the borrower's
qualifications. The commitment terms relating to interest rate and/or discount
points may be firm at the time of commitment or conditioned on the market rate
at the time of closing. If the decision is not to extend the credit, the lender
has 30 days from the acceptance of the completed application to notify the
prospective homebuyer. This notification must also include the reason(s) for the
rejection.
If the
loan is eligible for government insurance or guaranty, written agreements
stating so are issued. These can be either an FHA or Firm Commitment or VA
Certificate of Commitment. Conventional loans (not FHA or VA) receive an
application for private mortgage insurance if the down payment is less than 20
percent of the purchase price.
By now you
should feel a bit more at ease about what happens after you apply for a
mortgage. If you have a good credit rating, it will speak for itself. Also, it
is up to the lender to prevent homebuyers from over-extending themselves to the
point of losing their homes. Prudent underwriters should prevent this from
occurring.
Certainly
there will always be some anxiety associated with applying for a mortgage, but
if you understand the process, waiting for approval will be far less worrisome.